From TheAge
Asher Moses
September 7, 2007 - 2:00PM
Thousands of Facebook members are on the warpath after the social networking site removed images of breastfeeding mums and banned others for posting "obscene content".
They call themselves "lactivists" and say Facebook's practices are discriminatory.
Facebook's hardline stance on what its members can publish on their profiles is somewhat hypocritical given that it was caught running an image of a topless model in a banner ad for a dating service.
The mothers, many from Australia, started a petition in the form of a Facebook group called "Hey, Facebook, breastfeeding is not obscene!". The group now has almost 7000 members.
"Absolutely it is discriminatory and it makes me angry," said group member Pru Wirth, a mother of two from the central coast in NSW.
"If actual venues can be fined up to $40,000 for asking breastfeeding mums to cover up or move on, then why not a virtual public place?"
Another group member, Sally Millwood, from Petrie in Queensland, said: "I know from first hand experience breastfeeding can be a tough road to go down and, if you have success at the end of it, it's an amazingly proud and important achievement to be shared."
Facebook spokeswoman Meredith Chin said Facebook - which has more than 200,000 Australian members and 31 million users worldwide - did not prevent mothers from uploading photos of themselves breastfeeding their babies, but it did remove content that was reported as violating Facebook's terms of use.
"Photos containing an exposed breast do violate our Terms and are removed," she said.
It's not clear what constitutes an "exposed breast", which has the lactivists baffled.
Facebook did not respond to emails requesting further clarification but several group members have reported that their images were removed despite the fact they contained no nipple.
"Where does the feeding stop and the boob begin?? A peek of nipple?," one lactivist wrote.
Wirth, who is yet to have one of her own images removed, rejected Facebook's justification, saying there was a "real difference" between a user uploading their own images of their own body and Facebook themselves violating their own terms of use for profit.
"Regarding the case of the inappropriate banner ad that was posted, we have since removed the ad as it was a violation of our Terms of Use," said Chin.
In addition to removing particular photos from the site, Facebook has permanently revoked the membership of some of the mothers.
When one, Karen Speed, appealed and asked to have her account reinstated, Facebook said its decision was "final".
"We will not be able to reactivate your account for any reason," read Facebook's reply, published by Speed on her blog.
Wirth said it was important Facebook reconsidered its policy because it was restricting users from "sharing a normal part of our lives and our babies' lives".
She said Facebook had adequate privacy settings that allowed users to restrict access to their images.
"I can't see how sharing photos of your baby feeding with friends and family, or anyone really, could be deemed obscene," she said.
"If breastfeeding was done publicly more often it would just be the normal done thing, not something women should feel ashamed about, and it certainly wouldn't receive this kind of offensive reaction."
odd, bizarre, humor, satire, weird, comedy, politics, economics, lifestyle, offbeat, moral, philosophy, culture
Labels
Edison Chen
edison sex scandal
edison sex
sex scandal
Gillian Chung
cecilia cheung
陳冠希
sex photos
sex videos
Gillian sex
Manohara Odelia Pinot
Tengku Temenggong Mohammad Fakhry
prostitute
张柏芝
锺欣桐
malaysia
張栢芝
钟欣桐
big breast
breast augmentation surgery
humor
sex
sex slave
singapore
beer
breast implant
china
edison sex videos
jolin tsai
malaysian prince
oral sex
penis
prostitution
vincy yeung nude
woman
youtube
Bobo Nude
Charlene Choi
Gangnam Style
Gillian Nude
Herbal sex drug
OED
PSY
STDs
Serena Kozakura
Sufiah Yusof
Virgin
WONG MENG CHEE
Wee Meng Chee
adultery
airline passengers
airport
apple iphone
asian
big boobs
breast
breast enlargement
brothel
cecilia nude
cecilia sex
chinese
condoms
cosmetic surgery
death
divorce
english dictionary
english language
facebook
female
foreplay
gadis melayu
gender
herbal sex pills
hooker
immigration
indonesia
iphone
iphone hack
lovemaking
making love
malay girls
malay hooker
male
man
marriage
masturbation
maths genius
maths prodigy
monash university
moral of story
namewee
natual sexual enhancers
nicholes tse
older men
oxford
oxford english dictionary
pelacur melayu
plane
porn
rap
rapper
sex hormones
sex orgy
sex remedy
sex study
sex supplements
sex toys
singapore girls
sue
taiwan
underage girl
underage scandal
viagra
women
黃明志
2012
Adriana Lima
Adriana Lima Nude
Ahmad Fairuz Sheikh Abdul Halim
Alzheimer
Brazilian
Call Girl
Chanell Elaine Hallett
Cherie Chung
DD
David Carradine
Dawn Yang
E. Coli
Escherichia coli
Fiona Sit
France
GQ magazine
Genital Herpes
Gloria Allred
Greg Louganis
Guo Mei Mei
HIV
Hope Solo
Hsu Chi
Jill M Vidal
Joey Yung
Juno Mak
Kim Hyuna
Kira
Kpop
Kristin Davis
LaShawn Merritt
MV
Maggie Q
Mahathir Mohamad
Mandi Hamlin
Mani Fok
Music Video
Nazri Abdul Aziz
Olympics
Olympics 2020
Olympics 2021
PMS
Prevent genital herpes
RANZCOG
Ryan Lochte
STIs
STUDENT. international students
Schwartenmagen
Sex Gel
Sex Party
Sexually Transmitted Infections
Sheyla Hershey
Shu qi
Stephy Tang
TMZ
The moment of truth
Tianducheng
Tokyo
Tokyo Olympics
Tony Azevedo
Transportation Security Administration
UNIVERSITY
USA
V K lingam
Vietnamese
Vincent Hotel
VivaGel
Yumi
Yumiko Cheng
Zhejiang Guangsha
abyss creations
accident
addiction
advertising
age-related macular degeneration
airline
albert yeung
alcohol
angeline jolie
anwar ibrahim
apartheid
artificial vagina
athens
aussie women
aussieiphoneunlock.com
australia
australian sex gel
auto-erotic asphyxiation
baby airlines
baby flight
baby plane
ban breastfeed photo
ban breastfeeding photo
barbie
basketball
beijing
best sex
bestiality
bet
bikini model
bimbo game
blind
blow job
blow up doll
blue
bmw m3
bmw m3 challenge
bmw m3 coupe
bmw m3 game
bmw racing game
bobo chan
boob job
boobs
bourlon barracks
boycott
bra
bra cup
brand
brand recognition
branding
breast reduction
breast reduction surgery
bree conden
bugs
bumiputera
bumiputra
cameron diaz
canada sex party
cancer
car
career
career counselling
carina lau
casual sex
cathay pacific
childcare
children
children airline
children plane
children travel
china barbie
chinabarbie
chinabarbie.com
christy chung
color
colour
combat pilot
comedic
conman
consideration
contentment
contraceptive pill
corruption
crazy english
credit card
debt
demand and supply
dendrimer
depressed women
depression
designer vagina
designer vaginas
dictionary
direct marketing
disabled
discriminate breastfeed
discriminate breastfeeding
dollforum.com
donald trump
dragon white king
duke of lancaster's regiment
early learning
economic model
economics
education
electronic
elva hsiao
english
erogenous zone
exam stress
exposed breast
extend lifespan
facebook ban breastfeeding mum
fantasy
fatal
female doll
female libido
female orgasm
female sex
flight
france china
france shanghai
frank cleri
friends
funny
gamble
gambling
game show
gangnam style parody
german sausage
goat
goodness
greedy
hawker
health
heart
hessen
high debt
homer
homer simpson
honesty
hong lim
human lifespan
humility
humour
hyphens
indecency charges
indecent acts
independence
indian
insurance
intercourse
international Journal of Sexual Medicine
iphone china
iphone software patch
iphone software unlock
iphonesimfree
isabella leong
israel
japan
jet fighter pilot
jokes
kawanku
kids airline
kids flight
kids flying
kids plane
kids travel
kindy
kissing
kung fu
kungfu
labiaplasty
lactivists
lap dance
lars and the real girl
lauren cleri
libido
life size doll
livestream
london
long life
longevity
lord
m3 racing
m3 racing game
malaysia corrupt judge
malaysia corruption
malaysia crisis
malaysia judiciary
malaysia politics
male fertility
male hormone
mariah carey
marketing
maserati
masturbate
mattel
mederka
medical condition
men's health
mental health
microbicides
miko style
mile high club
military
miss korea
miss korea 2012
missbimbo
mistress
models
monks
moral
muscular dystrophy
my friends
myspace
nakazawa foods
negarakuku
neurotoxin
new bmw m3
new english terms
ninja
ninjutsu
nipple rings
nude
nurse
obesity
office sex
olympic sex
olympic village
olympics sex
online
online porn
online sex
orgy
paris china
paris in china
paris in shanghai
paris shanghai
patrick tse
pay
payment
pepsi
perseverance
personal finance
perspective
perve
perving
petting
phone sex
pink
plastic surgery
poker
police
polygamy
poo
pr
prevent HIV
prostate cancer
prostitutes
public indecency
public relations
public sex
public transport
quotations
quotes
racial
racism
racist
real doll
realdoll.com
realdolls
recall
reduce stress
richard li
robbery
royal australian navy
ryan gosling
ryanair
sabura allen
safety
scanner
security
sedition
seed
sensual spot
sex aid
sex and the city
sex ban
sex cheat
sex disease
sex doll
sex services
sex therapist
sex toys minibar
sexual services
sexy
shagbook
shaolin
shaolin kungfu
shaolin temple
social
software
solicit
southport
speed camera
stress
stressed adults
strip club
student
sudden weekly
summer games
super bowl
super premium milk
supermodel
swimsuit model
sydney
tanning booth
telemarketing
testosterone
thief
toddlers
toilet
trademark
traffic camera
trump vodka
trust
turbosim
twins
umno
venereal disease
victorian safety camera
victorian speed camera
vincy yeung
virginity
vodka
water
wine
winter games
winter olympics
woman libido
woman orgasm
work drinks
wurst
www.iphonesimfree.com
www.m3-challenge.com
young girls
younger women
天都城
小桜セレナ
我爱我的国家
我的朋友
李泽楷
梁洛施
舒淇
蔡依林
蔡卓妍
郭美美
陳文媛
강남 스타일
싸이